November 2002
Cash management poll 2002: Missing the point
All the global cash management banks continue to concentrate on the small pool of top-tier multinationals where there are opportunities to cross-sell but where competition is most intense. These most demanding of cutomers are driving down margins. The global players might be overlooking other sources of revenue.
Full results Methodology
The largest cash management banks seem surprisingly unconcerned by new competitors encroaching on their territory and by trends that threaten the revenues of one of their most important businesses. Even the fact that they are all pursuing the same strategy does not seem to worry them. Ask any of the global cash management banks to describe their strategy and they will give the same answer. They are all targeting the wallets of the top-tier multinationals.
The theory is that these multinationals are most likely to require complementary services such as foreign exchange and investment banking that banks hope to be able to cross-sell and also send and receive the most cross-border payments.
But these multinationals are also the most demanding of customers, have the most sophisticated in-house treasuries, and are the least likely to be willing to tie themselves to their banks. The falling cost and decreasing complexity of switching cash management banks now makes it possible and worthwhile for the largest corporates to review and re-tender their cash management needs more often and repeatedly to drive down the price and demand more. Moreover, according to Boston Consulting Group, revenue from cross-border payments is expected to fall at a compound rate of 1.3% a year until 2009.
With sophisticated corporate treasuries now able to do so much more to manage their cash by themselves, what do banks do to add value? John Hazelwood, EMEA head of product management at JPMorgan, concedes: "Revenues from traditional cash management services are under threat." But he says the banks can bundle services. "The ability to bundle services, particularly liquidity management such as cross-border sweeping, is a key differentiator," he says. "Our revenue base has historically been fairly evenly split between payments and liquidity products."
More information on cash management
This is archived content. Your current settings does not currently allow access to the archive. To gain access visit the subscription page or call our hotline on +44 (0)207 779 8999.
Are you already registered? If so, please enter your username and password here to continue.
Know your email address?
Click here for your password.
Questions about your subscription status?
Email us or call: +44 (0) 20 7779 8888
Subscribers to Euromoney benefit from:
- Exclusive access to euromoney.com - Read the latest issue early online, search for specific developments by region or sector, interrogate the results of Euromoney's benchmark polls, and view the archive dating back to 2000.
- 12 monthly issues of Euromoney magazine
- More than 30 specialist research guides free
- The results of Euromoneys polls and surveys
Click here to subscribe